JPMorgan Flags $2.8B Risk as MSCI May Drop Strategy from Indices

TLDR

• JPMorgan warned that Strategy may be removed from the MSCI indices on January 15.
• The removal could lead to passive outflows of up to $2.8 billion.
• An additional $8.8 billion in exposure remains if other index providers follow suit.
• Strategy’s stock has already dropped to levels seen during the pandemic.
• JPMorgan stated that losing index status could hurt liquidity and reputation.

JPMorgan has warned that Strategy (MSTR) may be ejected from the MSCI indices following the January 15 review. This could cause nearly $2.8 billion in passive outflows and affect an additional $8.8 billion. The firm’s exposure to Bitcoin and its structure could push it out of key benchmarks, according to JPMorgan.

MSCI Decision Could Lead to $2.8 Billion in Passive Outflows

JPMorgan analysts said Strategy could lose its place in the MSCI World and MSCI USA indices next year. They stated that the stock’s current classification and exposure to Bitcoin could influence the ruling. The analysts estimate this removal could drive passive outflows of up to $2.8 billion.

They added that another $8.8 billion in exposure would remain if other index providers follow MSCI’s lead. Passive funds that track these benchmarks may be forced to exit their positions. JPMorgan stated this would cause significant shifts in institutional exposure to Strategy.

“Strategy’s presence in indexes let Bitcoin reach traditional portfolios indirectly,” said JPMorgan analyst Nikolaos Panigirtzoglou. He added that this dynamic could change rapidly if MSCI removes the stock from its indices. The current market response reflects that possibility.

Index Removal May Affect Stock Liquidity and Reputation

JPMorgan believes that being dropped from MSCI indices could lower Strategy’s market liquidity. It might also hurt the stock’s appeal to institutional clients. Analysts said this could raise new concerns about the company’s ability to raise equity capital.

The firm currently holds over $9 billion in passive inflows through ETFs and index funds. JPMorgan noted that losing index exposure could also affect pricing efficiency and valuation support. “These effects usually materialize fast in modern passive-heavy markets,” the analysts said.

Strategy’s stock value has already dropped to levels last seen during the pandemic. Market participants appear to be reacting to the potential index reclassification. JPMorgan highlighted this as a reflection of sentiment tied to benchmark inclusion.

JPMorgan Says Strategy Resembles an ETF

The S&P 500 committee excluded Strategy from its latest update, citing structure and earnings issues. Robinhood, AppLovin, and Emcor were added instead. JPMorgan said Strategy’s profile resembles an ETF more than a company with recurring profits.

Benchmark analyst Mark Palmer said the company likely missed the cut due to earnings volatility. “The committee may want more clean quarters before considering inclusion,” he said. JPMorgan supported this view in its own notes.

Strategy Chairman Michael Saylor said he did not expect an immediate S&P 500 inclusion. “We’re a new concept making believers every quarter,” he said. Saylor remains confident about the firm’s long-term trajectory.

Strategy holds more than 638,000 BTC, currently worth around $72 billion. This amounts to about 3% of the total Bitcoin supply. JPMorgan said this makes the firm more of a financial entity than a software company.

S&P Dow Jones still classifies Strategy as a software firm under GICS. JPMorgan said this legacy classification affects index decisions. The analysts noted this mismatch may delay broader index inclusion.

The company’s market capitalization stands at $94 billion. JPMorgan said most of this valuation now relies on Bitcoin. Its Bitcoin holdings remain the largest among public companies globally.

MSCI Adds and Removes Dozens of Stocks Across Index Families

MSCI has added 69 securities and deleted 64 from the MSCI ACWI Index. JPMorgan said Strategy’s name was absent from both lists. This implies that further review may determine its status in the upcoming update.

Nebius Group A, CoreWeave, and Insmed are the three most significant additions to the MSCI World Index. GF Securities, Barito Renewable Energy, and Zijin Gold International are joining the Emerging Markets Index.

The MSCI ACWI Small Cap Index saw 207 additions and 224 deletions. JPMorgan noted that Strategy did not appear in these changes either.

MSCI’s next index review and rebalance will take effect on January 15, 2025. JPMorgan expects that the Strategy’s position will be finalized during that round. Index fund managers are preparing for potential rebalancing actions.

The post JPMorgan Flags $2.8B Risk as MSCI May Drop Strategy from Indices appeared first on Blockonomi.