Share
Share this article
Copy linkX (Twitter)LinkedInFacebookEmail
Opinion
Share
Share this article
Copy linkX (Twitter)LinkedInFacebookEmail
Grading America’s progress toward becoming t
Opinion
Share
Share this article
Copy linkX (Twitter)LinkedInFacebookEmail
Grading America’s progress toward becoming t
Grading America’s progress toward becoming the crypto capital of the world
Grading America’s progress toward becoming the crypto capital of the world
A year after issuing an open letter to the incoming Trump administration, crypto law experts reflect on their regulatory advice.
By Ivo Entchev, Olta Andoni, Stephen Rutenberg, Donna Redel|Edited by Betsy Farber
Jan 29, 2026, 4:35 p.m.
Make us preferred on Google
About a year ago, we published an open letter outlining practical, achievable steps an incoming administration could take to make the United States the crypto capital of the world, reflecting the views of the crypto law bar. The goal was not to promote crypto as an ideology, but to convey the perspective of lawyers working in the field on how thoughtful regulatory policy could unlock innovation and ensure that the next generation of financial and internet infrastructure would be built on American soil.
On the anniversary of that letter, as market structure legislation hangs on a knife’s edge, it is worth taking stock. The last year has been unusually eventful for U.S. crypto policy, and in many respects, the pace and scope of progress have exceeded even our more hopeful predictions. This moment calls for a kind of report card—one that both recognizes meaningful achievements and identifies the work that remains if the U.S. is to sustain and build on its leadership.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW
Don't miss another story.Subscribe to the CoinDesk Headlines Newsletter today. See all newsletters
Sign me up
Taking stock
Our letter focused on three broad priorities: supporting U.S.-domiciled crypto companies, promoting core crypto values in public policy and cultivating a welcoming domestic business environment for builders and entrepreneurs.
Since then, lawmakers have advanced forward-looking policies across all three fronts. Importantly, much of the progress has occurred not through sweeping legislative overhauls alone, but through sustained, pragmatic work at the agency level—work that has begun to replace years of uncertainty with a more coherent regulatory posture. While the job is far from finished, the overall direction of travel is unmistakably positive.
Supporting U.S.-based companies (letter grade: A-)
Our letter emphasized that U.S.-based crypto companies need clear, durable rules of the road to compete globally. We argued that market structure legislation was essential, but we also highlighted several specific sectors—stablecoins, decentralized finance and the integration of traditional finance—where tailored regulatory attention could unlock outsized benefits.
On this front, progress has been substantial.
General rules of the road
Momentum toward comprehensive market structure legislation has continued and Congress stands poised to clarify the respective roles of securities and commodities regulators in crypto markets—though it has most recently stalled amid disagreements over stablecoin yield. While a final statutory framework is still pending, the direction is clear: public blockchains are no longer regulatory black sheep but set to become a permanent part of the U.S. financial system, deserving of its own fit-for-purpose rules. As lawmakers approach the finish line on the market structure bill, we encourage them and the industry to resolve remaining disagreements in favor of open, innovative use cases rather than cement the advantages of incumbent crypto intermediaries, such as centralized exchanges. The bill is not perfect, but the diversity of industry stakeholders supporting it is an endorsement that it is good enough—and urgent enough—to become law.
Stablecoins
Here, progress has been especially notable. The passage of stablecoin legislation and the commencement of initial rulemakings have provided long-awaited clarity around issuance, reserves and supervision. This has given more U.S. companies a viable path to compete with offshore issuers, while protecting consumers from weak or opaque reserves and reinforcing dollar primacy in global digital markets. However, some of these victories are now at risk as the big banks attempt to reopen the Genius Act during market structure negotiations. Moreover, regulators must remain cognizant not to reduce crypto’s disintermediated infrastructure to merely the back-end for centralized custodial stablecoin issuers.
TradFi integration
The past year has also seen meaningful steps toward integrating crypto infrastructure into traditional financial markets. Banks, fintechs, asset managers and market intermediaries now operate with greater confidence that responsible engagement with digital assets will not invite reflexive regulatory backlash. This has opened the door to broader institutional participation, improved market plumbing, and more resilient financial rails. Unthinkable a year ago, key regulators, including the SEC, CFTC and OCC, are preparing for a financial system defined by tokenized securities, new on-chain asset classes and even decentralized finance and promising to cooperate on streamlining regulation for so-called “super apps” that span securities and commodities trading and other innovative products.
DeFi
Decentralized finance remains the most challenging category to regulate, but the conversation has matured. Regulators increasingly recognize that DeFi protocols do not fit neatly into frameworks designed for intermediaries, and efforts at distinguishing infrastructure (and its developers) from activity are bearing fruit. However, in codifying a control standard that distinguishes decentralized from centralized finance, lawmakers should take care not to draw the line so rigidly that DeFi protocols are discouraged from adopting basic safety and compliance measures, such as asset curation and sanctions screening, needed to protect users and comply with the law.
Much of this progress traces back to unusually visionary leadership at the Securities and Exchange Commission. Under new leadership, the SEC has moved away from regulation by enforcement and toward a serious effort to modernize securities laws for a tokenized world. That shift—now echoed by the CFTC—has done more than any single policy initiative to restore confidence among U.S. builders. Still, legislation insulated from political cycles and changes in agency leadership is needed to cement these gains, and the window to do so is rapidly closing.
Crypto values (letter grade: B+)
Crypto is not just a set of disruptive technologies; it is also a deeply American ideology rooted in openness, permissionless innovation, censorship resistance and individual autonomy. In our open letter, we argued that this meant that crypto must be treated the same as other technologies in certain contexts and differently in others.
Encouragingly, over the past year, crypto values have begun to find clearer expression in policy discussions and proposed legislation, such as around self-custody and privacy. That said, tensions remain. Crypto policy still oscillates between freedom-enabling instincts and reflexive containment driven by legitimate governmental concerns about illicit finance, tax evasion and national security. We remain convinced that crypto-native solutions, such as zero-knowledge proofs and portable identities, offer constructive alternatives to familiar regulatory approaches that rest on the financial surveillance of financial intermediaries.
Over the past year, regulators have made tangible progress in a range of important areas, such as repealing the IRS DeFi Broker Rule and reigning in OFAC enforcement, but other notable areas, like a comprehensive tax overhaul that does not unfairly punish crypto’s open and permissionless architecture, continue to lag.
The progress here is real, but uneven. Continued industry engagement will be essential to ensure that core crypto values are not gradually eroded through well-intentioned but blunt regulation intended to make things easier for regulators and traditional businesses. After all, crypto was not born to assist government, optimize finance or streamline applications. It was born to set people free. Regulation should not extinguish this core tenet by concentrating network sovereignty in the hands of the State or closed platforms, thereby sidelining the self-governing communities of builders and users that it was meant to serve.
A welcoming business environment (letter grade: B)
A year ago, we argued that regulatory clarity alone would not be sufficient to attract and retain crypto entrepreneurs. Builders also need a business environment that is predictable, fair and competitive with jurisdictions that have actively courted digital asset innovation.
The administration has made meaningful strides on this front. The tone has shifted decisively from hostility to engagement. Entrepreneurs are less susceptible to bureaucratic caprice and are more likely to encounter regulators who engage constructively rather than punitively. Notably, the OCC’s recent decision to grant national trust charters to fintechs and stablecoin issuers, as well as ongoing discussions regarding skinny master accounts, are an endorsement that blockchain-based firms should operate on an even plane with traditional financial firms.
Still, structural challenges persist. State-by-state fragmentation continues to impose real costs on startups. And while the overall posture is more welcoming, it has yet to translate into a truly frictionless environment for early-stage builders. For instance, despite the availability of DUNAs and 501(c)(4)s as domestic token stewards, projects continue to rely on offshore structures for tax reasons and greater certainty surrounding public token sales.
Room for improvement
Despite the overwhelmingly positive trajectory, the past year has also surfaced important cautionary lessons.
One development we did not foresee was the extent to which the president’s own family would become directly involved in crypto markets. Our original letter was published just days before the launch of a high-profile memecoin associated with the Trump brand. Whatever one thinks of memecoins as a category, this episode underscored the need for clear ethical guardrails to prevent the appearance—or reality—of conflicts of interest that could undermine public trust in crypto policy writ large.
More broadly, the next phase of American crypto leadership will depend less on regulators and more on builders themselves. Policy has opened doors; now it is incumbent on entrepreneurs to walk through them. The coming years will test whether crypto can deliver on its long-promised use cases: faster and cheaper payments, open capital markets, user-owned platforms and programmable financial infrastructure that serves real economic needs.
Looking ahead
If the last year has demonstrated anything, it is that progress is possible, and when it comes, it can be swift.
The challenge now is to consolidate those gains—to finish the work of market-structure legislation, deepen commitments to privacy and decentralization, and translate regulatory clarity into tangible economic growth. If builders rise to the occasion, the United States will not merely host crypto innovation; it will be the driver of it and shape its future.
One year ago, becoming the crypto capital of the world felt purely aspirational. Today, it feels achievable—provided lawmakers and industry actors remain clear-eyed, principled and ambitious about what comes next.
Ivo Entchev, Olta Andoni, Stephen Rutenberg, Donna Redel
The views represented and reflected upon herein are those of the signatories and not necessarily of their employers.
Note: The views expressed in this column are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of CoinDesk, Inc. or its owners and affiliates.
More For You
Pudgy Penguins: A New Blueprint for Tokenized Culture
Pudgy Penguins is building a multi-vertical consumer IP platform — combining phygital products, games, NFTs and PENGU to monetize culture at scale.
What to know:
Pudgy Penguins is emerging as one of the strongest NFT-native brands of this cycle, shifting from speculative “digital luxury goods” into a multi-vertical consumer IP platform. Its strategy is to acquire users through mainstream channels first; toys, retail partnerships and viral media, then onboard them into Web3 through games, NFTs and the PENGU token.
The ecosystem now spans phygital products (> $13M retail sales and >1M units sold), games and experiences (Pudgy Party surpassed 500k downloads in two weeks), and a widely distributed token (airdropped to 6M+ wallets). While the market is currently pricing Pudgy at a premium relative to traditional IP peers, sustained success depends on execution across retail expansion, gaming adoption and deeper token utility.
View Full Report
More For You
The fight over stablecoin yield isn’t really about stablecoins
It’s about deposits and who gets paid on them, argues Le.
Read full story
Latest Crypto News
Crypto bill clears U.S. Senate milestone as effort advanced through first committee
Ethereum OGs revive the DAO with $220 million security fund, Unchained reports
Crypto for Advisors: banks and digital money
Crypto custody firm Copper in early talks for IPO as crypto 'plumbing' becomes new Wall Street favorite
Live blog: Senate Agriculture Committee advances crypto market structure bill
Bitcoin's Quantum threat is ‘real but distant,’ says Wall Street analyst as doomsday debate rages on
Top Stories
Bitcoin tumbles to 2026 low of $85,200 as gold reverses big gains, Microsoft leads Nasdaq lower
Robinhood is investing in crypto trading platform Talos at $1.5 billion valuation
SEC clarifies rules for tokenized stocks, tightening scrutiny on synthetic equity
First gold and silver, now oil is starting to rally and that's bad news for bitcoin
White House to meet with crypto, banking executives to discuss market structure bill
Metaplanet is raising $137 million to pay down debt and buy even more bitcoin
Latest Crypto News
Crypto bill clears U.S. Senate milestone as effort advanced through first committee
Ethereum OGs revive the DAO with $220 million security fund, Unchained reports
Crypto for Advisors: banks and digital money
Crypto custody firm Copper in early talks for IPO as crypto 'plumbing' becomes new Wall Street favorite
Live blog: Senate Agriculture Committee advances crypto market structure bill
Bitcoin's Quantum threat is ‘real but distant,’ says Wall Street analyst as doomsday debate rages on
Top Stories
Bitcoin tumbles to 2026 low of $85,200 as gold reverses big gains, Microsoft leads Nasdaq lower
Robinhood is investing in crypto trading platform Talos at $1.5 billion valuation
SEC clarifies rules for tokenized stocks, tightening scrutiny on synthetic equity
First gold and silver, now oil is starting to rally and that's bad news for bitcoin
White House to meet with crypto, banking executives to discuss market structure bill
Metaplanet is raising $137 million to pay down debt and buy even more bitcoin
Disclaimer: The articles reposted on this site are sourced from public platforms and are provided for informational purposes only. They do not necessarily reflect the views of MEXC. All rights remain with the original authors. If you believe any content infringes on third-party rights, please contact service@support.mexc.com for removal. MEXC makes no guarantees regarding the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the content and is not responsible for any actions taken based on the information provided. The content does not constitute financial, legal, or other professional advice, nor should it be considered a recommendation or endorsement by MEXC.
You May Also Like
The Channel Factories We’ve Been Waiting For
The post The Channel Factories We’ve Been Waiting For appeared on BitcoinEthereumNews.com. Visions of future technology are often prescient about the broad strokes while flubbing the details. The tablets in “2001: A Space Odyssey” do indeed look like iPads, but you never see the astronauts paying for subscriptions or wasting hours on Candy Crush. Channel factories are one vision that arose early in the history of the Lightning Network to address some challenges that Lightning has faced from the beginning. Despite having grown to become Bitcoin’s most successful layer-2 scaling solution, with instant and low-fee payments, Lightning’s scale is limited by its reliance on payment channels. Although Lightning shifts most transactions off-chain, each payment channel still requires an on-chain transaction to open and (usually) another to close. As adoption grows, pressure on the blockchain grows with it. The need for a more scalable approach to managing channels is clear. Channel factories were supposed to meet this need, but where are they? In 2025, subnetworks are emerging that revive the impetus of channel factories with some new details that vastly increase their potential. They are natively interoperable with Lightning and achieve greater scale by allowing a group of participants to open a shared multisig UTXO and create multiple bilateral channels, which reduces the number of on-chain transactions and improves capital efficiency. Achieving greater scale by reducing complexity, Ark and Spark perform the same function as traditional channel factories with new designs and additional capabilities based on shared UTXOs. Channel Factories 101 Channel factories have been around since the inception of Lightning. A factory is a multiparty contract where multiple users (not just two, as in a Dryja-Poon channel) cooperatively lock funds in a single multisig UTXO. They can open, close and update channels off-chain without updating the blockchain for each operation. Only when participants leave or the factory dissolves is an on-chain transaction…
Share
BitcoinEthereumNews2025/09/18 00:09
Gold Hits $3,700 as Sprott’s Wong Says Dollar’s Store-of-Value Crown May Slip
The post Gold Hits $3,700 as Sprott’s Wong Says Dollar’s Store-of-Value Crown May Slip appeared on BitcoinEthereumNews.com. Gold is strutting its way into record territory, smashing through $3,700 an ounce Wednesday morning, as Sprott Asset Management strategist Paul Wong says the yellow metal may finally snatch the dollar’s most coveted role: store of value. Wong Warns: Fiscal Dominance Puts U.S. Dollar on Notice, Gold on Top Gold prices eased slightly to $3,678.9 […] Source: https://news.bitcoin.com/gold-hits-3700-as-sprotts-wong-says-dollars-store-of-value-crown-may-slip/
Share
BitcoinEthereumNews2025/09/18 00:33
XRP Escrow Amendment Gains Momentum, Set for February 2026 Activation
TLDR The XRP Ledger’s Token Escrow amendment has gained 82.35% consensus and is set for activation on February 12, 2026. This amendment allows users to escrow a
Share
Coincentral2026/01/31 01:00